Minitab Power and Sample Size: selecting a non-Wald interval method for one-sample proportion tests
0 reputation · 10 Feb 2021, 23:38 UTC
0 reputation · 10 Feb 2021, 23:38 UTC
I am using the Stat > Power and Sample Size dialog in Minitab (recent desktop version) for a one-sample proportion test. The dialog appears to compute its confidence interval using the default Wald method, and I cannot locate any option in the graphical interface to switch to a Wilson score or exact (Clopper-Pearson) interval.
My concern is that the planned sample sizes are small and the expected proportion is close to zero, a situation where the Wald interval is known to undercover. I would prefer to keep the entire workflow inside Minitab rather than exporting to an external script.
I am aware that the Session Command Language may expose an interval-method subcommand for the Power and Sample Size command, but the documentation I have found gives few concrete examples, and I am unsure whether the behavior is consistent across Minitab versions.
Is there a supported way—via dialog option or SCL subcommand—to make Power and Sample Size use Wilson or exact intervals for proportion tests? If SCL is required, what is the correct syntax, and does it apply to both sample size and power calculations? Are there version-specific limitations I should verify before relying on the output?
31775 reputation · 11 Feb 2021, 01:26 UTC
There is no dialog-level option in the Stat > Power and Sample Size > One Proportion interface to switch the interval method away from the default normal-approximation (Wald) basis. The only in-product route is to capture the Session Command Language (SCL) the dialog generates, edit the command to request a different method, and re-run it — but whether a Wilson or exact method is accepted, and whether it affects every output table, is version-dependent and must be verified on your installed release before you trust the numbers.
Confirmed by inspection: the dialog itself exposes no interval-method control, and the SCL it emits can be viewed and edited. Likely, but version-sensitive: the underlying Power command accepts a method-related subcommand in some releases, while other releases silently ignore unrecognized specifications and still report Wald-based intervals. Treat the SCL route as conditional until you have verified it on your version (see below).
METHOD or interval-method subcommand on the one-proportion Power command. Only use subcommand names documented for your version — do not guess syntax, because unsupported keywords may be ignored without an error.Staying entirely inside Minitab is still possible without the Power dialog: use Stat > Basic Statistics > 1 Proportion, which in recent desktop versions does let you choose the exact (Clopper–Pearson) method for the confidence interval, and iterate candidate sample sizes manually against your power target. This is slower but uses a fully documented, dialog-supported path. A short external check (e.g., an exact binomial power calculation) is also a reasonable cross-validation even if the deliverable stays in Minitab.
One detail that would sharpen this answer: your exact Minitab version (e.g., 21.x vs. the current desktop release), since the supported subcommands and output behavior differ across releases. Without it, the safe recommendation is the verify-then-trust workflow above rather than any specific syntax.
Use comments to ask for clarification. Post a solution as an answer.
No question comments on this page.