Karma and Chrome: Configuring retry behavior for browser disconnects
0 reputation · 18 Aug 2023, 16:15 UTC
0 reputation · 18 Aug 2023, 16:15 UTC
When running tests in Karma with Chrome, a browser may disconnect unexpectedly due to network hiccups or resource constraints. The goal is to determine whether Karma can be tuned to retry a disconnected browser more aggressively or to give up after a configurable number of attempts.
Current configuration options include browserDisconnectTimeout, browserDisconnectTolerance, and browserNoActivityTimeout. However, the retry logic that kills the current instance and launches a new one is hardcoded, and there is no flag to set the maximum retry count before failure. The community has proposed a browserRetry flag, but it remains unmerged.
Additionally, in autoWatch mode, a disconnect during a watch cycle may cause Karma to skip a retry and exit with an error, producing flaky CI builds. The behavior for browsers that do not support WebSocket is also unclear, as the tolerance setting is ignored.
Given these uncertainties, the following questions remain:
browserRetry flag been merged into any release, or is there an alternative workaround?31775 reputation · 19 Aug 2023, 00:06 UTC
There is currently no configuration flag in stable Karma releases to define a specific number of fresh browser instance launches (retries) after a terminal disconnect. The browserRetry flag proposed by the community has not been merged into the main stable branch.
While you cannot configure a "retry count" for launching new browser processes, you can tune how Karma handles the loss of connection to an existing instance. These settings are applied in your karma.conf.js:
browserDisconnectTolerance: This defines the number of times a browser is allowed to disconnect and reconnect before Karma fails the entire run. If a browser disconnects but reconnects within the timeout period, this counter is used.browserDisconnectTimeout: The duration (in milliseconds) Karma waits for a browser to reconnect before it considers the browser permanently gone and attempts to capture the failure or restart.browserNoActivityTimeout: The time Karma waits for a response from the browser before assuming it has hung.When autoWatch is enabled, Karma maintains a persistent connection to push updated assets. If a browser disconnects during this cycle, the behavior often differs from a single-run execution:
browserDisconnectTolerance is typically ignored because a stable connection was never established.Since native retry limits for browser launches are unavailable, consider these alternatives for CI stability:
browserDisconnectTolerance to allow for transient network hiccups, though this may mask memory leaks.To verify your current settings, check your configuration and simulate a crash:
# Check installed version
npm list karma
# In karma.conf.js
module.exports = function(config) {
config.set({
browserDisconnectTolerance: 3,
browserDisconnectTimeout: 10000,
// ...
});
};
Missing Diagnostic Detail: Are you running Chrome in headless mode within a Docker container? Resource constraints in containerized environments often cause the "hard" crashes that bypass browserDisconnectTolerance.
Use comments to ask for clarification. Post a solution as an answer.
No question comments on this page.