Elm Compiler and File‑System Cache: Interoperability of Cache Key with Compiler Version
0 reputation · 11 Aug 2022, 10:43 UTC
0 reputation · 11 Aug 2022, 10:43 UTC
The Elm compiler stores compiled interface files (.elmi) and dependency metadata in a file‑system cache under ~/.elm, using a hash that combines source file contents and package versions as the cache key. The goal is to understand whether this cache automatically busts when the underlying Elm compiler version changes, ensuring that builds reflect the correct compiler behavior without manual intervention.
Currently the cache key does not incorporate the Elm compiler version or certain command‑line flags (e.g., --optimize, --debug), so switching Elm versions or toggling flags can leave stale .elmi files that cause incorrect output or type errors. This behavior is noted as an unresolved decision in the Elm community, and users may need to clear the cache manually after a version upgrade. Given these points, the following questions remain: Does the Elm compiler presently include its version in the cache hash for .elmi files? If not, what are the recommended practices to avoid stale cache when upgrading Elm versions? Are there any open proposals or issues to modify the cache key to incorporate compiler version or flags?
29775 reputation · 11 Aug 2022, 18:04 UTC
The Elm compiler does not currently include its own version number or command-line flags (such as --optimize or --debug) in the hash used to generate .elmi cache files. The cache key is derived primarily from the source file contents and the version constraints defined in elm.json.
Because the compiler version is absent from the hash, upgrading the Elm compiler does not automatically trigger a cache bust. If a newer version of the compiler changes how interface files are generated or how types are resolved, the compiler may attempt to use stale .elmi files created by a previous version. This mismatch often manifests as unexpected type errors or incorrect binary output that does not align with the current source code.
To ensure build integrity after upgrading the Elm compiler or changing critical build flags, you must manually invalidate the file-system cache. Use one of the following methods:
elm make src/Main.elm --output=main.js --cleanrm -rf ~/.elm/cacheThere are known discussions and open issues within the Elm community regarding the modification of the cache key to incorporate the compiler version and build flags. However, as of the current stable releases, these changes have not been merged into the core compiler. Until an automated version-aware hashing mechanism is implemented, manual cache clearing remains the standard operational procedure for upgrades.
To verify if a stale cache is affecting your project, perform the following sequence:
elm --version to confirm the current installed version.elm make. If it fails with opaque type errors, proceed to the next step.rm -rf ~/.elm/cache and run elm make again. If the build succeeds, the previous failure was caused by cache interoperability issues.Use comments to ask for clarification. Post a solution as an answer.
No question comments on this page.