Does Material‑UI DataGrid getRows require manual AbortController handling to prevent race conditions under concurrent scrolling?
0 reputation · 05 Sept 2024, 13:19 UTC
0 reputation · 05 Sept 2024, 13:19 UTC
The goal is to keep the Material‑UI DataGrid displaying up‑to‑date rows when a user scrolls quickly, which triggers many rapid getRows calls for server‑side data. Each call starts a network request, and without coordination the grid may briefly show stale data or flicker as out‑of‑order responses overwrite newer results.
The DataGrid does not cancel earlier getRows invocations, and the experimental abortSignal parameter is not documented in the stable release. Developers must therefore decide whether to add manual AbortController logic inside getRows or rely on future library changes that might enforce request ordering. This leaves the cancellation strategy undefined and creates uncertainty about latency under high concurrency.
Should the DataGrid automatically cancel previous getRows invocations when a new request is triggered? Is exposing an abortSignal parameter in the stable API sufficient to resolve race conditions? What fallback strategy should be used for browsers that lack AbortController support?
35275 reputation · 05 Sept 2024, 22:51 UTC
In MUI v5/v6 the getRows callback already receives an AbortSignal as its second argument. If your implementation forwards that signal to any cancellable fetch or promise, the grid will automatically cancel the previous request when a new one starts. Therefore, manual AbortController logic is only required when you ignore the provided signal or use a non‑cancellable API.
When a user scrolls rapidly, the DataGrid issues many getRows calls. Internally it creates a fresh AbortController for each call and passes the signal to getRows. If you propagate that signal to fetch or any library that accepts it, the earlier request is aborted as soon as a new scroll event triggers another call, preventing stale data from arriving out of order.
getRows signature is (params, signal).signal to fetch(url, { signal }) cancels the request when the grid starts a new one.signal is ignored or a non‑abortable promise is used, earlier responses can overwrite newer ones, causing flicker.getRows receives a second argument named signal.
async function getRows(params, signal) {
const response = await fetch('/api/rows', {
method: 'POST',
body: JSON.stringify(params),
signal, // <- forward
});
const data = await response.json();
return data;
}
function abortableFetch(url, options, signal) {
return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
const controller = new AbortController();
signal.addEventListener('abort', () => controller.abort());
fetch(url, { ...options, signal: controller.signal })
.then(resolve)
.catch(reject);
});
}
abortcontroller-polyfill) or fall back to a simple request that ignores aborts but accepts the risk of stale data.
Does your current getRows implementation already forward the signal to the underlying network call?
With the stable API you do not need to create a new AbortController; just forward the supplied signal. Manual cancellation is only necessary when you ignore that signal or use an API that doesn’t support aborting.
Use comments to ask for clarification. Post a solution as an answer.
35,275 reputation · 05 Sept 2024, 19:33 UTC
Material‑UI DataGrid's getRows callback includes an AbortSignal argument in v5 and v6, but the component does not internally cancel prior network requests when new scroll events arrive. Forwarding the signal to fetch enables automatic cancellation, yet browsers lacking AbortController support require an alternative. A complementary mitigation pattern uses a monotonically increasing request token; the server echoes this token, and the client discards responses with stale tokens, preventing flicker from out‑of‑order responses. Both strategies can be combined: use AbortSignal for immediate cancellation where available, and maintain a request token as a fallback for older environments. Verification involves inspecting the network tab during rapid scrolling to confirm only the latest request remains pending, and logging token values to ensure stale responses are silently discarded.